ID or frat?

Discussion in 'The First Year' started by piccologirl, Jan 17, 2009.

  1. piccologirl

    piccologirl Well-Known Member

    our boys were mono/di and the perinatal specialist felt he saw the single placenta early enough that it was surely not two that had fused. it's not that i don't trust him, but i feel like they look very different. yes they have very similar features but what's most notable to me is their complexions. owen is fairer than jacob both in skin pigment and hair color (although that could be because owen has so much less hair). it seems like something like skin pigmentation would have to be the same if they're ID.

    owen is smaller and his head was more tapered than jacob's when they were born. i try not to let that throw me off. what do you think?

    a photo from today

    a slightly older photo

    my personal opinion is that these boys are frat or i'll eat my hat! :p we will be doing a DNA test at some point, of course.
     
  2. twinmommy2B2008

    twinmommy2B2008 Well-Known Member

    Your boys are adorable!!!

    I vote for ID. We don't see them every day like you do, so I'm sure it is easier for us to tell. I think my boys look different although everyone else has a hard time telling them apart. Also, the older mine get, the more they look alike.

    Let us know the results of the DNA test!
     
  3. lilsteff

    lilsteff Member

    They are too precious!!

    I am going with definately ID!
     
  4. j_and_j_twins

    j_and_j_twins Well-Known Member

    Identical lol its funny that the moms always say frat and everyone else says identical
     
  5. AimeeThomp

    AimeeThomp Well-Known Member TS Moderator

    They look id to me!
     
  6. KellyJ

    KellyJ Well-Known Member

    They are so ID and so cute!!

    I can't count the number of mom's that swear their ID twins are Frat., Even those who say they "know" they are Frat., they often don't look it to me. Fraternal twins look nothing alike and never get confused by anyone as ID, unless they are just one of those people. Unless you get a DNA test, you'll never know for sure unless they have a different blood type or are of different sexes! My son is friends with a set of Frats. and immediately no one thinks they are twins at all, ever. They sort of have a family resemblance, but just barely.

    I would trust your peri if he says they are mono-di, because they look like carbon copies to me. Ask your OB if they sent the placenta to pathology. That may give you a clue. Also, they often don't tell you they sent the placenta off, so you need to ask. Good luck!!

    Kelly
     
  7. Dianna

    Dianna Well-Known Member

    They look ID to me :)

    Dianna
     
  8. Moodyzblu

    Moodyzblu Well-Known Member

    I'm gonna have to say ID too ! :)
     
  9. jjzollman

    jjzollman Well-Known Member

    ID!!! (and Adorable!) :)
     
  10. meganguttman

    meganguttman Well-Known Member

    They are SOO FREAKIN' CUTE!!! I've ordered my DNA test and I've been asking since the boys were born. If you know you want to test, just do it now. I'm voting ID. Their eyes, nose and lips are the same.
     
  11. pamallhoney

    pamallhoney Well-Known Member

    My vote is for ID too! They sure are cute. Are their blood types the same?
     
  12. becky5

    becky5 Guest

    ID and so cute!
     
  13. PJ

    PJ Well-Known Member

    Oh my goodness they are cute! I think ID....
     
  14. tashatank24

    tashatank24 Well-Known Member

    They are So. Cute!!
    And I'd say ID
    But above all-- Super Handsome boys!!
     
  15. alex&andysmom

    alex&andysmom Well-Known Member

    Oh those cuties are ID!!!!!!!! :)
     
  16. brookbranplus2

    brookbranplus2 Well-Known Member

  17. marcymiller

    marcymiller Well-Known Member

    WoW!! They look ID to me. Mine are mono/di but I SWEAR they don't look ID very often!! Your guys ARE ADORABLE!!!!!!
     
  18. EricaG

    EricaG Well-Known Member

    SOOO cute! I vote ID.

    Erica
     
  19. MonicaBaker

    MonicaBaker Well-Known Member

    I vote ID!
     
  20. Jennifer P

    Jennifer P Well-Known Member

    They are ID
     
  21. Definitely identical, They are so handsome.
     
  22. ladybutterflyrose

    ladybutterflyrose Well-Known Member

    The definitely look ID to me and very cute :).
     
  23. AshleyLD

    AshleyLD Well-Known Member

    Did you really need to ask? They are SOOOOO ID and SOOOO cute~
     
  24. lianyla

    lianyla Well-Known Member

    They're identical. Testing would be a waste. TOTALLY ID without any doubt. FYI: all of us ID moms feel like you do!!
     
  25. kdanielleflowers

    kdanielleflowers Well-Known Member

    I hope you have a tastey hat because these boys are ID! (and so adorable to boot!)
     
  26. jenanne

    jenanne Well-Known Member

    Too adorable, and so identical to me! Just think that non-identical twins look as much alike as brother and brother, which isn't usually much :)
     
  27. piccologirl

    piccologirl Well-Known Member

    QUOTE(pamallhoney @ Jan 17 2009, 10:17 PM) [snapback]1151486[/snapback]
    Are their blood types the same?

    yes, all three of us have the same blood type.
     
  28. piccologirl

    piccologirl Well-Known Member

    QUOTE(blended6 @ Jan 18 2009, 02:11 AM) [snapback]1151637[/snapback]
    Totally ID

    LOL! didn't you think there was no way yours were ID? :p
     
  29. beemer

    beemer Well-Known Member

    Hope you picked a small but tasty hat... They look pretty ID to me.
     
  30. artemis

    artemis Well-Known Member

    ID!

    I can see why you'd doubt it, because you can tell them apart right now. But if you look at them feature by feature, you can tell they're identical.
     
  31. erinkontos

    erinkontos Well-Known Member

    I have felt the same way about my mono/di boys, as well. I vote ID for your adorable cutie-pies!!!!
     
  32. piccologirl

    piccologirl Well-Known Member

    DH is more convinced than i am that they're frat. i told him that everyone on TS thinks they're identical and he said, "then they're all crazy!" :p i have a feeling he'll even doubt the DNA test results when we do get around to doing the test.
     
  33. cmccarthy

    cmccarthy Well-Known Member

    ID for me too!
    Precious!
     
  34. angelf

    angelf Well-Known Member

    ID. And very cute! :)
     
  35. ddancerd1

    ddancerd1 Well-Known Member

    i have no idea, but had to say OMG THEY ARE SOOOO CUTE!!!!
     
Loading...
Similar Threads Forum Date
Identical or fraternal ? Pregnancy Help Feb 4, 2019
Fraternal twin boys months apart in development The First Year Aug 18, 2013
2nd set of Fraternal Boys Arrived! Pregnancy Help Jul 23, 2013
Identical to Fraternal and now confused General Aug 27, 2012
Why do my fraternal twins look identical? Childhood and Beyond (4+) Jul 21, 2012

Share This Page