Am I cruel?

Discussion in 'The Toddler Years(1-3)' started by KYsweetheart, Apr 20, 2007.

  1. KYsweetheart

    KYsweetheart Well-Known Member

    My guys are VERY scared of bugs...

    They wouldn't stay out of the fridge they kept opening it up and it was starting to defrost all the food... so I drew a bug on the door handle... now they won't go near the fridge!

    So since that worked so well, they kept trying to get out the front door, (I open the big door, so the storm door is open all day, and we can look out...) well they going out the door, even with the little handle locked, so I drew a bug near the handle and now they won't go near it either!

    Is that cruel or a new interesting way to keep them out of things?

    My mom told me it was mean!

    But hey, if it works it works.
     
  2. CraigS

    CraigS Well-Known Member

    QUOTE(KYsweetheart @ Apr 20 2007, 04:01 PM) [snapback]228244[/snapback]
    My guys are VERY scared of bugs...

    They wouldn't stay out of the fridge they kept opening it up and it was starting to defrost all the food... so I drew a bug on the door handle... now they won't go near the fridge!

    So since that worked so well, they kept trying to get out the front door, (I open the big door, so the storm door is open all day, and we can look out...) well they going out the door, even with the little handle locked, so I drew a bug near the handle and now they won't go near it either!

    Is that cruel or a new interesting way to keep them out of things?

    My mom told me it was mean!

    But hey, if it works it works.


    Personally I think its very creative.
     
  3. Susanna+3

    Susanna+3 Well-Known Member

    You have me cracking up here! But you might create a new problem... what if this causes them to get over their bug phobia and they start bringing bugs into the house!! :p
     
  4. momoftwingirls2005

    momoftwingirls2005 Well-Known Member

    Wow what a creative way to keep them out of things and from opening the door.
     
  5. Sue1968

    Sue1968 Well-Known Member

    I love it! I only think it's cruel if you are really trying to scare them (as a joke). I'd think your method is more like putting a Mr. Yuck sticker on the things they shouldn't touch. I wish it would work with my guys but only one is scared of bugs and he's pretty swift when it comes to telling fake from real.
     
  6. MommyTo3andCounting

    MommyTo3andCounting Well-Known Member

    I don't think it's mean, you aren't doing to watch them freak out, it's just a distraction tool. Wish something like that would work at our house, but my kids are all fascinated with bugs, that would just draw their attention there :laughing:
     
  7. rosie19

    rosie19 Well-Known Member

    I remember when I was a kid, those poison control stickers were the big thing... they were green and had a skull and cross bones on them. My mom used them on everything (not just poisionous cleaners and such) that she wanted me to stay away from. I don't think I was scared of the picture, the way your kids are of bugs, but it got the message across. I don't think it's cruel at all. They are not old enough for you to reason with them about the things you do not want them to touch. Instead, it is a visual way to get that message to them. I think it's pretty creative! It may not work forever, but if it works to keep them safe, it's a good thing.

    -Catherine
     
  8. KYsweetheart

    KYsweetheart Well-Known Member

    QUOTE
    what if this causes them to get over their bug phobia and they start bringing bugs into the house!!


    Good possibility... then I will be scared to death!! LOL
     
  9. Meximeli

    Meximeli Well-Known Member

    You do what works, especially when you have twins!

    I wish my kids were afraid of bugs. We are actually working on instilling that fear in them for their own protection. See this? This is a scorpion and it can sting you and it will hurt VERY VERY VERY MUCH so NEVER EVER touch one of these!!
     
  10. sharon_with_j_and_n

    sharon_with_j_and_n Well-Known Member

    Hey, whatever works. You're not cruel, you're innovative.
     
  11. MichelleS

    MichelleS Well-Known Member

    I actually think it's creative and quite funny! I don't think it's cruel at all.
     
  12. mandylouwho

    mandylouwho Well-Known Member

    I think its funny and creative too...I think it would be mean if you actually put a bug there, and tried to scare them with bugs. I think its great!
     
  13. FirstTimeMom814

    FirstTimeMom814 Well-Known Member

    Well let me share a personal experience with this. When I was a toddler I used to love to write in books and tear the pages out. My Dad of course was not a happy camper. My mom hung a little rubber spider (like the ones you can get at carnivals and such) on the bookshelf. I apparently was terrified of the bug and of course stopped destroying the books. To this day I am afraid of most bugs.
     
  14. Meximeli

    Meximeli Well-Known Member

    QUOTE(FirstTimeMom814 @ Apr 20 2007, 07:51 PM) [snapback]228596[/snapback]
    Well let me share a personal experience with this. When I was a toddler I used to love to write in books and tear the pages out. My Dad of course was not a happy camper. My mom hung a little rubber spider (like the ones you can get at carnivals and such) on the bookshelf. I apparently was terrified of the bug and of course stopped destroying the books. To this day I am afraid of most bugs.


    Trish, don't feel bad. I think at least 50% of adults are afaid of most bugs. I work in a place where we live fairly closely with bugs, and I work in a field with fairly high turn over, of our 15 faculty members, about 5 are new each year. I've seen a lot of people really really freak about bugs. Don't blame your mom, it's human nature.
     
  15. NicoleT

    NicoleT Well-Known Member

    Totally cruel Jamie!! Just kidding. I am cracking up though!! LOL
     
  16. MichelleL

    MichelleL Well-Known Member

    What a great idea! Not cruel at all and kudos to you for being so clever. I was cracking up! :rotflmbo:
     
  17. KYsweetheart

    KYsweetheart Well-Known Member

    Trish I am afraid of bugs too!! People make fun of me all the time! If it is a bee or a wasp you can guarantee to see me running in a different direction!!
     
  18. dfaut

    dfaut 30,000-Post Club

    I think it's funny!!!! :rofl: I would totally do something like that. We have to lock doors that they want to go out of and they aren't strong enough to open the fridge - thank goodness!!! I think it's clever and creative! YOU GO GIRL!
     
  19. jenn-

    jenn- Well-Known Member

    I think my response to this is based on their response to it. If all they do is see it and remember not to touch then that is fine and a good reminder tool. If they are freaking out when they get anywhere near it, that might be cruel.
     
  20. team_double.trouble

    team_double.trouble Well-Known Member

    haha, i can imagine walking into your house and seeing little bugs drawn everywhere, thats a good idea, my girls are so intreeged by bugs at the moment, they have no sence of fear yet.
     
  21. 2IrishBlessings

    2IrishBlessings Well-Known Member

    Wow what a good idea. That would have been helpful when they were younger. Heck No I dont think its cruel very creative!!
     
  22. r-twins

    r-twins Well-Known Member

    QUOTE(Sue1968 @ Apr 20 2007, 10:32 AM) [snapback]228290[/snapback]
    I love it! I only think it's cruel if you are really trying to scare them (as a joke). I'd think your method is more like putting a Mr. Yuck sticker on the things they shouldn't touch. I wish it would work with my guys but only one is scared of bugs and he's pretty swift when it comes to telling fake from real.


    I agree with everyone... you're not trying to scare them as a joke, I think it's a great idea. I'm going to try it tomorrow, but I'm not sure it will work. They don't seem to be afraid of bugs and spiders like their mommy is!!! :shok:
     
  23. Kryss

    Kryss Well-Known Member

    That is such a creative way to solve the problem !! good job mom :p
     

Share This Page